Since early Islamic History, there has been groups that have objected the authenticity of Hadith. H refuted them and they stopped their arguments. H responded to them and they stopped. These were the extreme Rawafid.
|Published (Last):||5 January 2005|
|PDF File Size:||17.49 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||18.77 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Yes there are early Hadith collections. In this article I will show evidences from non-Muslim Scholars that Hadith existed way before the dates they have brought forth.
First Century Hadith Collections. Sahifa Hamman B. It is well-known fact among Muslim scholars that Hammam B. Munabbih was a student of Abu Huraira. The earliest hadith collection we have extant is Sahifa b. Munabbih which was written by the student of Abu Huraira.
Of the four remaining collections, the earliest is the Sahifah of Hammam b. Munabbih d. Munabbih, d. Singh, he goes in detail on Hadith and also comments on Sahifa B. He writes:. We are told that Ali b. Al-As has also collected by permission of the Prophet, some Traditions in a book, which he named as al-Sahifa al-sadiqa. Similarly, Jabir b. Abdillah d. Abu Huraira and Amr b. Hazm are also reported to have gathered some Traditions while the latter had also committed to writing a number of such letters of the Prophet as he had despatched to the neighbouring rulers inviting them to embrace the new faith.
Abu Huraira, a close companion of the Prophet, had preserved and transmitted a large number of traditions. Apart from oral transmission, he is reported to have dictated some traditions to his pupils who committed them to writing. Hammam b. Munabbih compiled a book entitled al-sahifa, of which the manuscripts are found in the libraries of Berlin and Damascus. Its Arabic text along with the Urdu Translation and necessary notes has recently been published by Dr.
Rashid, a disciple of Hammam, also compiled a book entitled Jami, Manuscripts of which are in the Ankara University Library and in Istanbul. Abu Bakr Abd al-Razzaq b. We have seen that Abu Huraira, his pupil Hammam b. Hanbal have made continued efforts in preserving and compiling the hadith literature. After the discovery of these works we may rightly suppose that there must have been some other compiled works which did not come down to us.
Nay, dictation or writing of such material was rather looked down upon as compared to oral transmission. His article is massive, I am just going to present his Conclusion. He was one of the most highly respected scholars of fiqh Islamic Jurisprudence in Sunni Islam. Imam Malik while he was alive compiled a Hadith book. One if the Muwatta or Beaten Track of malik b. Anas d. Professor Clinton Bennett. The earliest extant musannaf work is the Muwatta of Medinan Scholar malik b.
He says:. As more texts of hadith and early Islamic law have become available, several scholars have analyzed these materials, correlating the Isnad the supporting chain of authority for such hadith itself in more painstaking and systematic ways than Schacht had done in his day.
Whatever Muslim Scholars of the past have said on Hadith reliability, now non-Muslim Scholars affirm this truth. I believe everything I have brought forth in this article from Academic sources thoroughly debunk missionary and Hadith-rejecter lies. Singh volume 1 Page [Author Kr. This article is a thorough refutation to Hadith-rejecters. This evidence alone will show that Hadith are part of the Deen of Islam.
But if they turn away, then Allah does not like the disbelievers. And how excellent these companions are! They ask you O Muhammad about the spoils of war. O you who believe! Messenger Muhammad while you are hearing. Islamic Monotheism and all that Islam orders one to do , and forbid people from Al-Munkar i. Allah will have His Mercy on them. As you have read the above verses, Allah has made it clear that Obedience to the prophet is obedience to Him. There are two distinct commands in the verses shown.
According to these self-made scholars, it means to obey the Quran. Here is a challenge for Hadith rejecters. And whatever the Messenger has given you — take; and what he has forbidden you — refrain from. And fear Allah ; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty.
That is better and more suitable for final determination. As you see, this is enough proof that prophet Muhammed p was more than just a delivery-man. This verse Quran proves that he the Prophet was more than just delivering the Quran. So it is those who believe in him, honour him, help him, and follow the light which is sent down with him,- it is they who will prosper.
This is another beautiful verse, where Allah states clearly that the Messenger has authority to prohibit and allow. With clear signs and Books We sent the Messengers. There are 5 theories going around by the Hadith-rejecters, I will answer them God willing one by one. They love playing with words. B illustration n. C elucidate v. D clarify v. E explain v. This second theory is really amusing. These people just make things as they go along.
What he is saying is that, Allah gave the best understanding of the Quran at the time of the Prophet, while he was alive and who ever came after the prophet was a lost sheep. According to him Allah only explained the Quran to people at the time of the prophet Muhammed p.
Another thing he is saying is that Allah failed to preserve the explanations, teachings of the prophet. What this individual is doing, he is making up his own theories, making up lies not to follow Hadith and deceive people, even though deep down he knows Hadith are from the prophet Muhammed p.
Another person came with another theory that prophet Muhammed only explained the teachings of the Quran to the Jews. His proof was the previous verse, before and Another thing they believe, not all of them, but some do. They havent provided any evidence for this claim. Source: Edward Lane Lexicon Volume 1, page This last claim, by Hadith-rejecter is taking the biscuit.
This person was bringing verses from there and there, mingling up and making his own interpretation. The person acknowledges that is true, and that Prophet Muhammed p did indeed explain the Quran, but there is twist to it. If anyone reads the verse from start to end, you will see the verse is very clear, that prophet Muhammed pbuh is the one that will explain.
Here are few questions for this individual and the people who have that sort of belief. If the Quran is easy to understand, why does the prophet need to explain through the quran?
Why does the prophet need to interpret, explain to people to understand the Quran, if the Quran in itself is explained already? Our Lord! You are the All-Mighty, the All-Wise. Another proof from the above passages that Prophet Muhammed p was to instruct people in the Quran with wisdom. What is Instructing?
Here is an explanation:. Sunnah, Islamic laws and Fiqh — jurisprudence , and teaching you that which you used not to know. In the above verses Allah has made it clear that the prophet pbuh teaches people the Quran with the wisdom.
How do we know what the prophet taught if it is not in the Quran? Where is the knowledge wisdom Allah gave to the Prophet p , if it is not in the Quran? A prophet of Allah humbled himself to take knowledge from a man more knowledgeable than him. He used to receive revelations from Allah, yet he was in need of knowledge from someone who knows more? If all the Prophet p had to do, to understand the Quran, is to read the verses.
Hadith Rejectors Claim: The Qur’an is Sufficient
Yes there are early Hadith collections. In this article I will show evidences from non-Muslim Scholars that Hadith existed way before the dates they have brought forth. First Century Hadith Collections. Sahifa Hamman B. It is well-known fact among Muslim scholars that Hammam B.
Reply to common arguments of Hadith Rejectors
Anyone who obeys the Qur'an has no other option but to obey the Messenger, Salla-Allahu alayhi wa sallam, too. Had we been living with him, we would have no hesitation in blindly following his orders. We accept Allah's Word that He has protected the Quran from corruption, but why should we accept the words of these hadith collectors? Are they as infallible as Allah? Hadith is the same as the gospels of Christianity.
Are Hadith Necessary? An Examination of the Authority of Hadith in Islam
The previous articles in this series have given us a clear picture of the Importance of Sunnah and Hadith, and how Islam would have Naudubillah been incomplete without it. The articles are a tiny little compilation from the massive library of scholarly work on the subject. But as for a person who has closed his heart already, instead of reflecting on the points made, he only comes up with silly arguments regarding various issues ranging from authenticity of Hadith to making claims that some Hadith classified as Saheeh contradict the Quran, etc, etc. And this has always been the case of people who deny the clear proofs. They want to keep you busy answering their questions so that you never get time to make your own point. No matter how many arguments you answer, they will always keep coming with more.
Hadith Rejectors: Exposing a Hypocrites Movement
Quranism is similar to movements in Abrahamic religions such as the Karaite movement in Judaism and the Sola scriptura view of Protestant Christianity. Quranists may also refer to themselves simply as Muslims , Submitters , or reformists. These are the verses of God which We recite to you in truth. Then in what statement [Hadith] after rejecting God and His verses will they believe? Quranists believe that the Quran is the sole source of religious law and guidance in Islam and reject the authority of sources outside of the Quran like Hadith and Sunnah.